Tax Advice

Size isn't everything except maybe when it comes to negotiating with HMRC

28 Jan 2016

Everyone knows the biblical tale of David v Goliath. It is an inspirational story that small businesses can use to show that size isn’t everything.

David, an Israelite armed with a staff and a sling defeats the heavily armoured Philistine giant Goliath.

This story has become a metaphor for the power of the underdog, but it appears Goliath may always win when it comes to the tax system, especially if you are a big multinational company like Google, Starbucks, Apple or Facebook.

Downing Street Fence

Chancellor George Osborne and HMRC have been criticised after letting the internet search giant, Google, get away with paying a settlement to cover £130million of tax dating back to 2005.

The company’s tax status has come under fire because of the way it directs its sales and profits through Ireland to effectively reduce its bill.

Its sway in the UK has also been demonstrated by other settlements where it has actually paid more. For example, it has agreed to pay £380million of owed tax in France, suggesting the taxman in the UK has less mettle when it comes to taking tax from big companies.

The issue has led to calls for Margrethe Vestager, the EU’s antitrust commissioner, to investigate the settlement.

HMRC is often criticised for reduced tax settlements it agrees, known as sweetheart deals, as these are often reserved for global behemoths while small companies and startups toil and struggle to get their returns in on time at risk of instant penalties.

HMRC Building

Other companies such as Apple and Facebook have also come under the spotlight for how much tax they pay due to the way they structure their companies around the world.

While not illegal it raises questions over whether small businesses and entrepreneurs would get away with setting up their companies in such a complex way and if the taxman would be so willing to negotiate.

Lobby group the Tax Justice Network has estimated that Google should be paying about £200m every year in corporation tax in the UK, but paid just £20.5million in 2013 on its UK profits when it declared $5.6billion in UK revenues, according to the Financial Times.

Google has responded to criticism, writing in the FT that it is complying with “international tax rules and how they work.”

Google Laptop

Keir Wright-Whyte


Managing Director

0207 043 4000

About the author

Originally graduating with a degree in geography from Edinburgh University, Keir claims that he was then tricked into becoming an accountant by one of the UK's top 5 accountancy practices.The deception extended to the usual training in audit and associated activities.

Keir subsequently worked in a number of advisory roles with clients including in the energy trading, pharmaceuticals and financial services sectors.

He loves working at Accounts & Legal because of the variety of work and clients, the excellent team ethos and morale, the importance placed on genuinely helping and being useful for clients and because he believes what he does matters to clients and helps the firm.

Keir's primary role is to ensure that new clients with complex businesses or needs are on-boarded in the best way and he is a "trouble shooter" both for clients and where complex issues arise internally. He also helps the accounting teams strive to improve what we do for clients, whether processes or services.

When not debiting or crediting, Keir has a penchant for fixing old buildings, skiing, surfing and cycling.


We can help you grasp opportunities


If you’re self-employed and thinking of starting a business, we can help plan ahead and get your accounts in order. We are full-service accountants offering tax and accounting support from bookkeeping to business plans, and payroll to tax-efficient investment advice.


Call us today or get an instant quote for our services!